Your business has backups. But if ransomware encrypted your servers tomorrow, would those backups survive, and could you really restore their contents? That is the question raised by the 3-2-1-1-0 backup, a mnemonic formula that extends the well-known 3-2-1 rule. This article explains each number, what the Canadian Centre for Cyber Security (Centre canadien pour la cybersécurité) (the Centre) recommends, how to test your copies and what to do if an incident occurs.
One clarification first: the 3-2-1 rule appears in the Centre's guidance. The 3-2-1-1-0 formula is not an official standard: it is a practice of the backup industry, which the vendor Veeam describes in a blog article as the 3-2-1 rule plus one immutable (or isolated) copy and zero errors when verifying the restore. We cite this vendor for the origin of the formula, without recommending its products. Its last two numbers match recommendations that the Centre makes in other words (offline copy, restore tests). Below, we distinguish what comes from the Centre, what comes from industry practice and what is general good practice.
Why backups are the first line of recovery
According to the Centre, ransomware is malicious software that prevents you from accessing your systems, devices and files until you pay a ransom. Its page on ransomware states that cybercriminals use malicious software to "encrypt, steal or delete data" and that, in double extortion, they also threaten to publish the data if the ransom is not paid.
In its publication ITSAP.40.002 (June 2024), the Centre writes that thanks to backups, you will probably not need to pay the ransom, while specifying that paying does not guarantee that your data will be returned. It adds an important limit: backups help you restore your systems, but they do not prevent an attacker from selling or disclosing stolen data. A good backup strategy addresses unavailability, not leaks.
The 3-2-1 rule according to the Centre
The Centre recommends the 3-2-1 rule: three copies of the data (the original and two backup copies), on two different types of media, including one off-site copy.
- 3 copies: if one copy is corrupted or deleted, others remain.
- 2 different media: a failure or an attack affecting one type of media does not take everything down.
- 1 off-site: the Centre notes that storing only on site exposes you to loss in the event of a fire or flood at the premises, and recommends a copy at another location.
The last two numbers: "1" and "0"
The first "1": an offline or immutable copy
The Centre recommends having one backup copy stored offline. An offline (or "cold") backup, it explains, is not connected to the organization's systems except when necessary; when it is truly disconnected, it is less exposed to ransomware that compromises systems and devices connected to the network.
On its National Cyber Threat Assessments page, the Centre also recommends developing, testing and implementing a backup plan that uses offline, isolated or immutable backups, and observes that some attackers delete connected backups before demanding the ransom. (The page we read does not state the edition of the report.) The term "immutable" refers, in common industry usage, to a copy that can be neither modified nor deleted for a defined period; the Centre does not define it in the pages we read.
The Centre also issues warnings about everyday media:
- removable media (external drives, USB keys) are convenient, but can be damaged, stolen or lost; they must be removed from the device after the backup to be protected from an attack on the network;
- network-attached storage (NAS): attackers can target it and ransomware can spread to it, which would compromise the backups.
An external drive left permanently plugged in, or a NAS accessible with the same credentials as the workstation, is therefore not an isolated copy.
The "0": zero errors, that is, tested copies
The "0" means, in common usage, zero errors on verification: a backup that has never been restored is a hypothesis. The Centre goes in this direction: among the elements to consider, it lists "testing the recovery process with the backup" and "testing backups to verify that they work", as well as describing how the recovery process is carried out, including roles and responsibilities.
As a general good practice, a useful restore test follows these steps:
- Regularly pick a system or a data set at random.
- Restore it in a separate environment (never over production).
- Open the files, launch the application, check that the data is readable and consistent.
- Record the actual time required: this is your measured recovery time.
- Record the discrepancies and correct them.
The Centre does not set a single frequency; it asks you to determine it (daily, weekly, monthly) in your policies.
Encrypt, protect access, choose the essential data
The Centre recommends encrypting sensitive data to protect it, making sure the storage device has security controls (encryption, malware scans, a proper process for sanitizing and disposal) and keeping backups separate from the computer, on an external device or a cloud solution protected by a strong password or passphrase and multi-factor authentication.
It also recommends identifying the essential data, the data required to operate with the bare minimum, and setting priorities. For an SME, this comes down to answering: what must be restored first to invoice again, deliver and pay staff?
As for backup types, the Centre describes the full backup (recommended regularly, weekly or monthly, and before any major upgrade; the most costly and time-consuming), differential and incremental.
And the cloud?
The Centre points out that cloud storage can offer many advantages, notably the provider's expertise. But it reminds us that your organization remains legally responsible for protecting its data at all times. Check that the provider meets your security requirements (encryption, incident management, disaster recovery plan) and take data residency into account, since your organization may have regulatory requirements imposing storage in Canada.
In Quebec, the Commission d'accès à l'information (Quebec's access to information commission) specifies that a business must carry out a privacy impact assessment and meet the applicable legal requirements, notably those relating to the adequate protection of the information disclosed, before disclosing personal information outside Quebec: this may concern a backup service whose servers are outside the province. Check this before choosing.
Checklist for an SME
- Three copies in total of the data (the original and two backup copies), on two different types of media, including one off-site copy.
- At least one offline, isolated or immutable copy that cannot be modified with everyday credentials.
- Separate backup accounts, strong password or passphrase, multi-factor authentication.
- Sensitive data encrypted.
- Essential data identified, with a restore order.
- Written policy: frequency, responsible people, recovery process.
- Restore test scheduled and documented, with measured time.
- Cloud provider assessed (security, incidents, data residency).
- Response plan: who to call, how to isolate a device, how to report.
If the incident occurs: isolate, recover, report
The Centre's page "Rançongiciel : comment vous en remettre" (Ransomware: how to recover) says to isolate the device, identify the ransomware (decryption tools exist for certain variants only) and follow a suitable recovery procedure. Once the ransomware is eliminated, you must apply security updates and patches and change the passwords of the accounts used from the infected device. Without a decryption tool, backups are "very valuable". It warns that paying the ransom does not guarantee that the data will be recovered and that copies may remain in the hands of the perpetrators.
Reporting. The Centre encourages reporting cyber incidents; this helps it protect Canada. Its recovery page recommends contacting your local law enforcement agency and the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre (Centre antifraude du Canada).
Legal obligation in Quebec (personal information). According to the Commission d'accès à l'information, the business must notify the Commission and the people concerned of any confidentiality incident presenting a risk of serious injury, and keep an incident register. This is not a recommendation: it is a legal obligation. A data theft linked to ransomware may fall within it; have your case assessed by your person in charge of the protection of personal information. This article is not legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
Is cloud synchronization (OneDrive, Dropbox) a backup? The pages we consulted do not address this specific case. Synchronization can also propagate deletions or encryption of files; check the recovery mechanisms available, notably version history and how long it is kept. Ask your provider.
How often should you back up? The Centre asks you to determine it by policy (daily, weekly, monthly) according to the importance of the data and the loss you can accept.
Is a backup enough against ransomware? No. It lets you resume your activities, but it does not prevent the disclosure of stolen data, hence the importance of prevention, encryption and reporting.
Should you pay the ransom? The Centre states that paying does not guarantee that the data will be recovered. The decision remains the organization's, with its advisors.
KTMA SOLUTIONS expertise
Sources
- Veeam Software — What is the 3-2-1 Backup Rule? (vendor blog, updated July 3, 2026) (accessed )
- Canadian Centre for Cyber Security — Backing up and recovering your data (Sauvegarder et récupérer vos données; ITSAP.40.002, June 2024) (accessed )
- Canadian Centre for Cyber Security — Ransomware (Rançongiciels) (accessed )
- Canadian Centre for Cyber Security — National Cyber Threat Assessments (Évaluations des cybermenaces nationales) (accessed )
- Canadian Centre for Cyber Security — Ransomware: How to Recover (Rançongiciel : comment vous en remettre) (accessed )
- CAI — Main changes introduced by Law 25 (Principaux changements apportés par la Loi 25) (accessed )

